Tuesday, August 20, 2019

Black Sheep - Elizabeth Fones Winthrop Feake Hallett


How would you like to read a story that includes Indian massacres, abusive politicians, the colonial turf wars in Connecticut (Dutch? English?), the oppressiveness of religious institutions (those Puritans didn’t stand for any nonsense!), the drawing of town and state lines, the growing influence of the Quakers, all intertwined with one woman’s stormy life? I’ve mentioned this ancestor before but she fills the bill for this week’s prompt: Black Sheep. Though I would classify her more as a pioneer and survivor, for the times in which she lived I’m sure she was a black sheep – she definitely stood out! Born in 1610, Elizabeth Fones was the daughter of Thomas Fones, an apothecary in London, and Anne Winthrop. Anne’s father, Adam Winthrop, was a wealthy Suffolk clothier. His success enabled him to join the gentry and so the Winthrops became squires and lords of Groton Manor.
John Winthrop, later governor of Massachusetts
In 1629 Elizabeth married her first cousin, Henry Winthrop, son of John Winthrop who later became the first governor of Massachusetts. John was a devout Puritan and lawyer, and became the leader of the Winthrop Fleet, the first 1000 settlers to sail to Massachusetts with the Massachusetts Bay Company. 
In 1630, Henry left for Massachusetts aboard the Talbot in Winthrop’s Fleet (after being too late to catch the Arabella and travel with his father some months earlier.) Elizabeth remained in England awaiting the birth of their first child. On 2 July, the Talbot arrived in Salem, intending to then proceed to Charlestown. Henry saw a native canoe on the opposite side of the North River. He jumped in the river to investigate, but a few minutes later he was "seized with cramps" and went down in full sight of his friends, who could not swim.
Elizabeth arrived in Massachusetts 2 Nov 1631 with her new baby. She made the crossing on the Lyon with several family members and about 100 other passengers.
Within months of arriving, her uncle Governor John Winthrop encouraged her to marry Lt. Robert Feake, a wealthy landowner. The Feakes acquired more land in what is now Greenwich, Connecticut. Elizabeth is considered one of the founders of Greenwich; the area now called “Greenwich Point” was earlier known as “Elizabeth’s Neck” in recognition of Elizabeth Fones and the 1640 purchase of the Point and much of what is today Old Greenwich. The deed reads: "...except ye neck by ye Indians called Monakewago, by us Elizabeth Neck, which neck is ye peticaler perchace of Elizabeth Feaks, ye sd Robt Feaks his wife, to be hers and her heaires or assigns, forever….” Undoubtedly, Elizabeth used her own money, probably what she inherited from her father’s estate, to make this purchase. The fact that a woman held property in her own name was viewed with dismay in the rigid society of that time.
Elizabeth Neck (now Greenwich Point, Connecticut)

Elizabeth and Robert had five children; Elizabeth, Hannah (through whom we descend), John, Robert and Sarah.

Robert began to exhibit signs of mental illness fairly early in the marriage and eventually abandoned his family by living apart and then returning to England. Elizabeth later married Robert’s business manager, William Hallett. This was scandalous in the Puritan world because it didn’t appear that Elizabeth and Robert had divorced, and he was still alive. (Robert eventually did return to America and ended up being supported by the town of Watertown between 1650 and his death 12 years later, still insane.) In 1966 Donald Lines Jacobus reviewed this sticky problem, and came to the conclusion that Robert Feake and his wife did obtain a divorce from the Dutch government, that she had married William Hallett by August 1649, and that the marriage was performed by John Winthrop Jr., her former brother-in-law. Because of the scandal, Elizabeth and William left Connecticut for the Dutch Colony of New Netherlands/New York and settled in an area called Hallett’s Cove, now known as Astoria, Queens, near Hell Gate.
Map detail showing Hallett's plantation (now Astoria, Queens)
In September 1655, their family, now including two sons, William and Samuel, survived an attack by the Hackensack tribe of Indians. The house and farm buildings burnt to the ground. Elizabeth then purchased land in Flushing and Newtown. The following year William was made the chief official of Flushing. In 1664 William purchased all of Hell Gate Neck, Riker’s and Berrien’s Islands from the Indians for the sum of 58 fathom of wampum, 7 coats, 1 blanket, 4 kettles.
Since writing the original story about Elizabeth, I've learned that we also directly descend from her son William Jr. from husband William Hallett.  (William Hallett >> William Hallett Jr. >> Rebecca Hallett >> John Jackson who married Sarah Doty - 3 generations before is our Mayflower ancestor, Edward Doty >> Mary Jackson >> Rachel Shotwell >> Phebe Laing >> Edward Harned >> Harriet Yardley Harned >> Edgar Charles Forman . . .)
Upon the marriage of daughter Hannah Feake to John Bowne, Elizabeth and William Hallett joined them in becoming Quakers. The Puritans who had made her life so difficult had not turned her completely from God. Elizabeth died about 1665 (some records say 1673) at about age 55 in Newtown, Queens County, New York. William died in 1690. As descendants of Elizabeth Fones Winthrop Feake Hallett, as well as of her daughter Hannah Feake Bowne, we have famous company. Amelia Earhart, John Kerry, Bill Gates and Johnny Depp are also descendants!                       

Read more about our illustrious ancestress: 
Insubordinate Spirit: A True Story of Life and Loss in Earliest America 1610-1665 by Missy Wolfe (this is a well-researched book)

Winthrop Woman by Anya Seaton (this is more of a fictionalized version)

Our Pedigree from Elizabeth: Elizabeth>>>Hannah Feake>>>Mary Bowne>>>Jacob Thorne>>>Mary Thorne>>> Jacob Laing (at this point, if we followed his wife Rachel Shotwell, we’d arrive at our Mayflower ancestor, Edward Doty)>>>Phebe Laing>>>Edward Harned>>>Harriett Yardley Harned>>>Edgar Charles Forman . . .

Originally posted at FamilySearch.org Memories

Thursday, July 25, 2019

An Unexpected Pioneer Ancestor

Pioneers camped at Green River, Wyoming by George Ottinger
On April 16, 1847, a group of 148 Latter-day Saints in 72 wagons left Nebraska and began the 1,031-mile journey to the Salt Lake Valley. They arrived in the Salt Lake Valley between the 21st and 24th of July 1847.
In the years that followed, tens of thousands of Latter-day Saints from around the world would leave their homes and follow the same route to the Salt Lake Valley. This week in Utah we celebrate Pioneer Day on July 24th, in commemoration of that first company of Latter-day Saints who arrived in the Salt Lake Valley in 1847. Since Dad (Ward H. Forman 1926-2006) was the first of our family to join the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, our pioneer ancestors are few, and not direct. But we are related to some of those hardy souls who risked it all to travel to the west where they could worship as they pleased, much as our Mayflower and Puritan and Quaker ancestors did. Surprisingly then, this pioneer story is from Mom’s (Josephine T. Forman 1925-) side of the family! A common ancestor on the Canham side was Emma Girdlestone. This is a bit of her story.
Emma Girdlestone Ridges Smith
Born in March 1835 in Norfolk, England, she joined the church after hearing the missionaries preach in her town. She immediately knew their message to be the true gospel of Jesus Christ. She was baptized at 13 years old. Her parents joined as well. When the gathering to Utah was advised, they saved and prepared to leave their native land and loved ones to start a new life in a foreign land. Emma and her parents left England in the spring of 1856, when Emma was 21. After many delays, they departed from Iowa City, Iowa in July 1856 with the Willie Handcart company. The company had about 500 individuals, 100 handcarts, and 5 wagons when it began. Some days they traveled as much as 30 miles, pushing and pulling their handcarts.
Emma's hand iron, carried across the plains
Emma was a seamstress by trade and she brought her hand iron with her on the trip. Since the travelers were only allowed 17 lbs of belongings each, she could not put the iron on the handcart, but instead tied it to her waist and carried it across the plains. 



  Fall came on early and hard that year. Company provisions ran low causing rations to be cut down to one-half, then one-quarter, and still later to just barely enough to sustain life. Many grew ill from exposure and lack of food.
Ever Onward by Joseph Brickey
The Saints in Salt Lake didn’t learn of the existence of this and other stranded handcart companies until early October. At that point Brigham Young issued an urgent plea to the people for assistance. The first relief company left Salt Lake City 3 days later. By October 19th, the Willie company issued the last of their flour, and the first snowstorm of the season hit. Express rescuers arrived that day and assured the Willie company that help and food were just a day or two away. On October 21st, the needed supplies arrived. They then made a brutal trek over Rocky Ridge in Wyoming during a blizzard on October 23rd. 15 members of the company were buried the next day. Emma’s parents died within 4 days of each other during this time period. Now she was on her own.
Pioneers Entering the Salt Lake Valley by King Driggs
Ten supply wagons met the Willie Company on October 31st, west of Green River. By November 3rd, additional teams had reached them and all the company members were able to ride in wagons. They arrived in Salt Lake City on 9 November 1856. Emma told her descendants that as they came into the valley the sun was shining and flooding the valley with its glory; it looked like a Heaven of peace and rest to those weary travelers. Emma married twice and had at least 8 children, and has a very large posterity now. She always bore a strong testimony of the truthfulness of the gospel. She died in 1914 in Logan, Utah.

Though not all Latter-day Saint pioneer stories were this dramatic, and some were much worse, in general the people were willing to sacrifice in order to gather with others of common belief and live free to practice their religion. Of special note is that the Willie Company also included several members of the Moulton family, ancestors of Annette’s husband, Jess Moulton, as well as several Caldwell family members, who are ancestors of my husband, John D. Van Natter.

A version of this story was originally share at Family Search Memories 22 July 2018

Wednesday, July 24, 2019

With Faith in Every Footstep


Since we came into possession of the Forman Bible and learned we are descended from the Longstreet family, this year we have more Mormon Pioneers to celebrate!

Will of Samuel Longstreet (1735-1829) naming his daughter Mary, wife of Isaac Forman
But they didn't all come by land.

Mary Ann Shinn Burtis Robbins
Samuel Longstreet had a sister Andrea who married William Burtis. They had a son Abner, who married Rachel Shinn (who emigrated from Ireland with her 3 sisters.) Abner and Rachel Burtis had a daughter Mary Ann (my 2nd cousin 5 times removed) while they lived in New Jersey. She married Isaac Rogers Robbins in 1838. They joined the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints in 1840 and traveled to Nauvoo, Illinois to join the Saints there. But poor health sent them back home to New Jersey.

At the request of Church leaders, Samuel Brannan procured a sailing vessel for a company of Saints living on the east coast, to make their way to join the Saints in the west via sea voyage around Cape Horn. All but 12 of the 238 passengers were church members, including Mary Ann and Isaac Robbins, and their 3 children. They sailed on 4 Feb 1846, the same day the Saints began their exodus from Nauvoo. It was a hazardous voyage due to storms, scurvy, and low fresh water supplies. They crossed the equator on both the Atlantic and Pacific Oceans, went from the icy Antarctic to the tropical Hawaiian Islands and then on to California. They finally landed in Yerba Buena (now San Francisco) on 31 Jul 1846. Their nearly 6 month journey had covered about 24,000 miles.

Voyage of the Brooklyn 1846
After a year and a half, a company was formed under Ebenezer Brown which included, among others, the Robbins family and a group of returning Mormon Battalion veterans. They traveled for two months from Pleasant Valley, California, on the newly-constructed Carson Pass wagon road over the Sierras to Salt Lake Valley. The hard life took its toll on Mary Ann, and she passed away at the age of 38 on 11 Jun 1849, the same day their oldest son, Joseph Reeves Robbins (age 9) also died. Her husband Isaac took the 3 remaining children and settled in Provo. Isaac married Abiah Russell Carter in 1852, and had 11 more children!

They traveled with an unshakable faith in God. Their descendants number now in the thousands.


Faith in Every Footstep

1. A marvelous work has begun to come forth among all the children of men.
O ye that embark in the service of God, give heart, mind, and strength unto him;
For prophets have spoken and angels have come to lift the world from sin,
That Christ may reign over all the earth and bless his gathered kin.
Chorus
2. Those marvelous Saints who embraced this great work and shared it in lands far and near;
Who gave all their heart, mind, and strength to the Lord with wisdom and vision so clear;
Now stand as examples of virtue and faith, of souls prepared to hear,
Of knowledge sure, born of humble heart, and love that banished fear.
Chorus
3. If we now desire to assist in this work and thrust in our sickle with might;
If we will embark in the service of God and harvest in fields that are white;
Our souls may receive the salvation of God—the fulness of his light,
That we may stand, free of sin and blame, God’s glory in our sight.
Chorus
Chorus
With faith in every footstep, we follow Christ, the Lord;
And filled with hope through his pure love, we sing with one accord.
Copyright © 1996 LDS. All rights reserved. This song may be copied for incidental, noncommercial home or church use. This notice must be included on each copy made.














Monday, July 22, 2019

The Name of Baragwanath


Benjamin Baragwanath, @1885
This is Benjamin Baragwanath, born 11 Jul 1862 in St. Ives, Cornwall, England, the first photo of any of our Baragwanath ancestors. 

"Baragwanath" is a Cornish surname originating in west Cornwall in the United Kingdom. Due to emigration the name can be found in South Africa, Australia, New Zealand, the United States and the United Kingdom.

"Bara gwanath" means "wheaten bread" or possibly "the top of the wheat field." Legend says the first of that name came from Wales. The early Baragwanath men were likely millers or bakers. The name first appears in Cornwall, England in the early 1600s when John Baragwanath married Eleanor Jenkin, and they had eight children.

1954 Jamie Forman's Christening (Ben is on the far right)

Baragwanath family members in photo: 
Left: Annie Elizabeth Baragwanath Forman holding Jamie Forman, Edgar Charles Forman, Florence May Baragwanath, Ben Baragwanath, Ross Forman, Ivan Forman.








As one who bears the name - Kathleen Baragwanath Forman Van Natter, I have always had mixed emotions about it. I was named after my father's mother, Annie Elizabeth Baragwanath Forman. My mother always said she thought it was such a lovely name, and spoken with her Scottish brogue, it isn't too bad. But with a flat American accent, it's small wonder that my friends would say, "Your middle name is Iguana?" This past Christmas season though I had a new awakening to this name as I pondered on the meaning of the name Bethlehem: House of Bread. How similar in meaning that was to Baragwanath. Which led me to consider Jesus Christ - The Bread of Life. All three have that staple of life in common: bread.
“Jesus teaches us, His disciples, that we should look to God each day for the bread—the help and sustenance—we require in that particular day,” said Elder D. Todd Christofferson of the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. Bible Video here: I Am the Bread of Life - Jesus Christ

A version of this story was originally published at Family Search Memories 11 Feb 2018

Saturday, July 20, 2019

Showy Silver Fittings - Our Quaker Ancestors' Response (Harned, Vail, Comly)

I find the Quakers in our family lines fascinating, and so when I find new stories that illustrate their proclivities I just need to share them! The illustration of this carriage is from 1863, the time of the story below, but is from a carriage manufacturer in New York. 

Rachel Harned and Lindley Murray Vail (2nd great-great aunt & husband)
Emma Mott Vail, daughter of above, & Samuel Comly (1st cousin 3 times removed & husband)

Before he was the president of a nuts and bolts company in Westchester, New York, which allowed his wife the privilege of having a full-time cook, Samuel Comly was a carriage-maker. (He's tiny - only 5' 1" according to his passport application.)

The following story comes from Comly Family in America: Descendants of Henry and Joan Comly Who Came to America in 1682 from Bedminster, Somersetshire: with short accounts of the ancestors of Charles and Debby Ann (Newbold) Comly,  which is available at Ancestry.com and other places for download.

In 1863, before going to Port Chester [New York], and while a carriage maker in Byberry [a neighborhood in the northeast section of Philadelphia], Samuel's father-in-law [Lindley Murray Vail] asked him to  make a carriage for him. Samuel took unusual pains with it, made the cushions thick and comfortable and, as a finishing touch, put on silver door handles and hub caps. His father-in-law was much pleased with everything except the silver fittings, which he thought too showy, so Samuel painted them over.

Quaker practices included plain speech, modesty, and avoiding "showy" things. Like silver fittings on your carriage. Emma and Samuel were Quakers as well, so perhaps Samuel was willing to forego his true feelings about being "showy" to impress his father-in-law. Or maybe Samuel just liked the fine silver handles, and hub caps!




Wednesday, July 17, 2019

Sister Project - If you could change one thing about yourself...

Linda, Annette, Kathi, Claire - Lake Tahoe 1963

The question posed 20 or so years ago was: 

If you could change one thing about yourself, what would it be?  2019 answers follow


Linda: That depends on the age and stage.


Childhood: I wanted straight toes and tried to correct them with popsicle stick splints.
School years – I sure wished I had nice skin on my legs, and not the bumpy variety I was plagued with.
High School – My biggest complaint was vision – squinting to see the chalkboard and then never wanting to wear my first pair of glasses.
College – Why couldn’t I have had better teeth? I don’t ever remember NOT taking care of them!
Motherhood – This is a no-brainer and has to be “weight!” Always a struggle…
Early Midwest – What happened to my hair when we moved to Iowa is not something I want to describe.
Now – All of the above are still issues, but now I add joint troubles which I’ve battled for over a decade.
My consolation is something Brent told me when he was a little boy: “Just wait for the resurrection, Mom. That’ll fix you up!”
2019: I have had this discussion with myself many many times. And I can never settle on one thing. I wish I had better eyes. I wish I was thin. I wish I had better skin. I wish my toes didn’t curl. I wish I didn’t have stiff joints. I guess I will go with good joints and no arthritis! Now if this question was supposed to be about a quality of character, I would say that I wish I wasn’t such an introvert.

Kathi: Sometimes I think it would be nice to live my life without a blue lip. Just to see what it's like. But there are so many other worse things that it's hard to be too whiny about something like a blue lip (hemangioma is the medical term- an overgrowth of blood vessels.) I also wish I was the size I was at age 19!!
2019: I’d want to change how much of an introvert I am. I’d like to be that happy, friendly soul who greets everyone, can talk to anyone, and loves to socialize. I hardly want to leave my home because I’m so happy and content in my little cocoon. I absolutely crave solitude too, which is the antithesis of the social creature I think I should want to be. I’m happy as I am, but I feel I should want to be different. Does that make any sense?

Claire: I would really like to have more height.  I'm only 5'1", and though it was always cute and adorable growing up being so short, it hasn't helped in my adulthood. I can hardly reach into my kitchen cupboards, I don't see the dust on the mantle or think to clean above the frig. I'm glad my kids didn't get my height, they are more like their dad, taller than me!
2019: My height. Being short used to be cute and adorable but it's not practical anymore. 

Annette: Only one?? Okay, my initial thought was bodily changes but I'll try to appear less superficial and think of something deeper and more profound! Once someone turns on me in any way (even if I find out they said something behind my back) I have a hard time trusting them again in the future. I'm like the proverbial elephant who never forgets. That's not good! I need to change that!
2019: I worry too much about the expectations of others. 

Tuesday, July 16, 2019

William Lake Forman (1829-1919) - IN THE CENSUS


Early in my research I was following William Lake Forman through the census records at the Family History Library in Salt Lake City. The 1850 U.S. Census is the first with family information and I found him easily living with his widowed mother Eliza, sisters Mary and Emma, and brother Isaac. So on to the 1860 Census.
1850 Philadelphia PA census
I knew he married Amanda but didn't yet know the date, so it was possible he was married by 1860. When I couldn't locate him at all, I finally realized I should also search with the spelling"Foreman". And I found a William "Foreman" living with the Charles and Esther McAllister family in the 2nd Ward of Philadelphia where he'd lived in 1850. This was a likely candidate as there was no other by that name in the city. But there was a problem: This William Foreman is married and has a one-year-old son named William (which checks with our records) but his wife is listed as "Mary."

1860 Philadelphia PA Census
So is this William Foreman, married to "Mary", living with the McAllister family our William Lake Forman? I decided to assume this was him, and that the enumerator had simply transposed Amanda's sister Mary's name, listed right before William on the census form, as his wife. The 1870 Census shows I was correct as William Foreman and Amanda Foreman have a son William, age 11. The father William is also listed as a house painter in all 3 of the censuses. But I hadn't known Amanda's maiden name until finding her and William living with her parents.
1870 Philadelphia PA Census
Then I found their marriage announcement in the Philadelphia Inquirer newspaper, published on 8 Sep 1853. "On the 4th inst. by the Rev. G. Owen, Mr. William L. Foreman to Miss Amanda O. McAllister, all of Southwark."
And a family is made. By the way, in all later documents, including a signature of his from 1889, his name is spelled "Forman."

(First published in Family Search "Memories" 4 Feb 2018)